The Lady of Sing Sing

This extraordinary book of historical non-fiction has the shape of drama as old as the Greeks with vivid relevance to the way we live now. The cast includes a young illiterate immigrant woman from Italy, an American woman of wealth and idealism, and a major historical figure named Thomas Edison. A murder drives the story. But woven through the tale are rich themes of class, shame, cruelty, kindness, loneliness, empathy, and yes, love. Pick it up!

A real-life story found in an old chest provides all the drama needed today for film roles for women. In 1890s Manhattan, abuse and rape led to a crime that churned up a nation already rumbling about women’s rights.

The plot has all the elements of a first-rate, well-crafted thriller. A crackling page-turner, it is an eye-opening document about life and social attitudes at the turn of the century.  As such, it tells us a great deal about how much we’ve learned as a society in a hundred years, and how little.

Combining her own family history with Barbella’s story, Pucci investigates the sensational crime [and] its equally sensational aftermath.

In the spirit of sensational trials across the ages, Idanna Pucci pulls out all the stops.

Maria’s story – starting with the murder itself – is told with chilling page-turning immediacy. But the book takes an interesting novelistic turn in the portrayal of its two protagonists – Maria and Cora. By shifting the narrative focus between the two women, the author dramatically contrasts their very different backgrounds and personalities and their inverse relationship to each other.

A taut, energetic and skillful collage of narrative styles and genres: part gripping crime and courtroom drama, part vivid historical portrait of turn-of-the-century New York City. And it is partly an eloquent meditation on the death penalty and women’s rights.

This is a splendid and important book about Gilded Age justice in New York.  A true tale story that reads like a verismo opera of naiveté, lust, and abuse. It opens the way for more scholarly studies that question the historic notions of this supposed formalistic age of draconian justice against immigrants and lower-class types who traduced the rules and always lost. In fact, as this case points out, Gilded Age New York was a more nuanced period in which defenses of honor were pervasive and the road of legitimate revenge, sanctioned by a New York County’s jury quasi-nullification verdicts could assimilate operatic heroines from southern Italy in a court of law even against the formidable odds of the positive law of Anglo-Saxons.

Idanna Pucci has skillfully crafted Barbella’s suspenseful story and documented late-19th-century prejudice against Italian Americans and women, as well as the inhumane treatment of prisoners. Gripping social history.